Pool builders sometimes oversimplify the fiberglass vs. gunite question. “Fiberglass is cheap, gunite is custom” is the most common shorthand — and it’s wrong on both ends. Here’s the more honest comparison for Middle Tennessee pool buyers.
Fiberglass Isn’t ‘Cheap’
Quality fiberglass pools from premium manufacturers (Leisure Pools, San Juan, Latham, Thursday Pools) cost only modestly less than comparable gunite. The cost difference is often less than buyers assume. Fiberglass is generally less expensive — not “cheap.”
Gunite Isn’t Always ‘More Custom’
Modern fiberglass shells come in 50+ sizes, shapes, and configurations including tanning ledges, sun shelves, swim-outs, and elaborate steps. Most pool buyers’ “custom” requirements are met by available fiberglass models. Gunite is fully custom — fiberglass is highly customizable.
The Real Tradeoffs
Fiberglass: faster install, smoother surface, lower maintenance, shorter material warranty period, fewer algae issues. Gunite: fully custom shapes, longer history, can be resurfaced, longer install, more chemicals required, more textured surface.
Which Is Right for Most Tennessee Backyards
For most Middle Tennessee homeowners, either works. The choice usually comes down to: do you want a unique shape or specific size that fiberglass doesn’t offer? If yes, gunite. If no, fiberglass typically delivers excellent value with less maintenance.
Ready to Get Started?
Good Day Living installs both — we’ll help you make the right choice for your specific situation. gdayliving.com or (629) 299-1460.
